Testing a therapist is all well and good, but what if they just plain suck? What then?
Whose problem is this? Is it really that bad, or is it just me? Am I the problem?
Many dissociative survivors are so conditioned to feel perpetually at fault for everything around them that they genuinely can’t distinguish whether something “should” be their fault or not. It all feels like their fault. So trying to determine whether a therapist is genuinely helpful, genuinely safe, genuinely trustworthy, can seem like an impossible task, regardless of how many tests we put them through or how many months or years we sit in their office giving it the good old college try.
This difficulty is only compounded by the number of people who have had some kind of previous negative experience in therapy… and those numbers are unfortunately large.
So how can we provide ourselves with that little bit of emotional protection going in, so that we don’t end up getting screwed all over again in a situation where we were hoping for help?
First, a few things not to do…
DON’T jump into therapy and spill your guts right away. This might seem like a good idea ahead of time – a way to jump-start the process quickly before second thoughts make you clam up – but it’s also something you are likely to regret so strongly that it might end up destroying your therapy. With the passage of time, regret over hasty revelations can (and very often does) turn into resentment toward the therapist who was there to hear them. Many therapy relationships have been destroyed over this kind of regret – and there’s no need to set ourselves up for this. Therapy is a long-term investment that will not benefit from attempts to rush it along – and secrecy is bred into the very bones of dissociative disorders. We need to respect that, even as we begin working to change it.
AND, DON’T take someone else’s opinion of your therapy over your own – not your therapist’s, not your friend’s, not some online idiot’s. (And yes, that includes me – the minute I start intruding on your personal space and trying to impose my opinions on you, instead of just posting them in my own blog and letting you decide what, if anything, to do with them, is the moment at which you should start ignoring me, if you aren’t already.)
Other people can sound very compelling in what they have to say – and they might be right, or they might be wrong – and they might have your best interests at heart, or they might have their own agenda which they are pushing on you, or they might have their own issues which they are projecting onto you, or they might have their own obscure needs which they are acting out through you – this can be true of anyone. The point is, you don’t know.
Nobody is guaranteed to be safe or trustworthy or honest.
I find it mind-boggling, when survivors are so hypervigilant about a therapist’s safety or trustworthiness, but then they go to the opposite extreme of blind trust when it comes to other people in their lives. Survivors will allow themselves to be played like a deck of cards by family members, friends, and other survivors, without even considering whether or not they should have been worried about their safety with those people, but put them in front of a therapist and suddenly it’s all sharp claws and protective defenses.
I’m not suggesting that we should not exercise this much care with our therapists – what I am suggesting is that we should be just as careful when it comes to everyone else in our lives. Therapists are not the only people capable of hurting us or lying to us or deceiving us or manipulating us, so they should not be the only people toward whom we exhibit such fierce self-protection.
Nobody comes with a guarantee. We should not extend blind trust to anyone, or ever assume that someone is trying to help us just because they say they are. This applies to therapists, and to friends, co-workers, colleagues, fellow survivors – none of them can be assumed to have our best interest at heart, regardless of what they say.
But – this doesn’t mean we lock ourselves away, abandon all hope of healing, never reach out for friendship, never open up again. It means we learn to trust ourselves over and above every other person around us, so that we are less vulnerable to being hurt or manipulated by others.
The only motives we have any likelihood of ever being able to understand or rely on are our own – and the difficulty of understanding ourselves does not excuse us in letting other people lead us around by the nose because we can’t be bothered to figure it out. Such willing self-abdication is inevitably and invariably a recipe for trouble.
We need to learn to have our own best interest at heart, and how to listen to our own gut about what is and is not right or safe or trustworthy for us.
When it comes to therapy, this means listening to ourselves as much as to the therapist, and to the complete exclusion of anyone who thinks they know our private situation better than we do. All therapists are likely to say they are helping us – and some of them will even mean it – but not all of them are capable of being as helpful as they want to be, and some of them really do just suck. And plenty of people will have an opinion to share about therapy in general or about our therapist in particular – but since we can never know where their opinion is really coming from, we should be careful as to how much weight we give it – especially when it is telling us something that completely contradicts our own experience, or when we don’t have enough personal experience to reasonably evaluate that opinion.
Our own experience should be the guiding voice in our own decision-making process.
Because whether or not we are able to communicate easily with our internal world, our own experiences and reactions can give us a very a reliable sense about our therapist…
… apart from the typical “we can’t trust anyone, that person says we should trust them which automatically makes them bad, bad person, must get away, can’t trust anyone” and etcetera…
… and apart from the typical “change is bad, this person has no business in our world, we don’t want anyone messing in our shit, change is evil and they want change, therefore they are evil and anyone who listens to them is stupid” and etcetera…
… and apart from the typical “I suck, I don’t know why this person is even being nice to me, they must have an ulterior motive, I wonder what it is, I certainly can’t believe them…” and etcetera…
… basically, apart from all the things that we’d be hearing about anyone, or about any therapist (because if the same phrases or ideas or reactions are applied indiscriminately, then they probably shouldn’t be taken seriously as a reflection of the situation at hand, they are more a reflection of the biases and fears and concerns of the person or group saying them)…
… apart from all this, there will still be some truths that can actually be helpful to us if we listen to them.
How does the therapy make us feel? It shouldn’t necessarily make us feel good… because good therapy will push into some very uncomfortable places, and it can confront us with some really unwelcome truths about ourselves, and both of these are hard to hear, and neither of them feel good… so good therapy actually involves a lot of feeling bad… but good therapy should make us feel supported, even despite the hard things. It shouldn’t make it comfortable to be the way we are (because obviously, we are there to change, and the first precursor to change is not being comfortable where we are), but it should feel like a place where it is okay to recognize the truth of how we are and what we do, what happened to us and what it did to us and what we’ve done to ourselves in order to cope… therapy should be where we can face our own fear and shame, our own wounds, our own traumas, face them honestly, without turning away… because the therapist is willing to face them with us, with honesty and compassion… and then we can work on changing them.
That’s a tough role to fill, because if something is succeeding when we leave feeling tired or disturbed or distressed, that can really complicate our ability to determine whether or not there’s a problem, but at rock bottom, I guess the only question we really need to ask ourselves is – do we feel like the therapy is helpful to us, or not?
If therapy with a particular therapist does not feel helpful, then that’s really enough. We don’t have to have a “good reason”. It doesn’t have to be anyone’s fault, and we don’t have to point fingers on the way out the door. If it doesn’t feel right for any reason or no reason at all, that’s really and truly still enough.
As I noted in this post, there are multitudes of ways that therapy can get done, and thousands of therapists in practice – so we never have to accept working with a therapist we don’t like or an approach that doesn’t feel like it suits us.
In therapy, despite the confusing emotional components, you are a consumer. You are never obligated to stay in a therapeutic relationship you don’t like or that doesn’t feel like it’s working for you.
So… listen to yourself – if your therapy doesn’t feel like it’s working for you, then don’t let anyone argue you into doubting your own sense of needing a different approach to your own healing. And conversely – if your therapy is going well, don’t let anyone talk you into seeing a problem where there isn’t one. People have all sorts of motivations for trying to convince you to think what they think instead of letting you think for yourself – but their motivation in such a case is rarely your best interest.
Find and follow your own instincts as to what is right for you and what isn’t – this is the simplest and safest and most reliable way to keep others from hurting or manipulating us.
Be your own best friend and your own best protection.
Be your own final word.
Your background does not have to include programming, mind control, ritual abuse, or cult activities to make your child alters vulnerable to a predator’s approach. All a predator requires is a malleable mind and an uncritical perspective, and any child alter will give them that.
6. Keep in touch. Talk to your child alters about the outside people with whom they interact. Even if you saw every word of the conversation, this is still important. As with any child, keeping yourself interested and involved in their activities will maintain a strong bond between you, and consistent attention can enable you to pick up on developing problems much more quickly. Some signs of possible trouble include the child alter appearing reluctant to repeat the conversation, any claims that they can’t or are not allowed to repeat what was said, or appearing more secretive than usual. Even if the conversation looked innocuous to you, these can be signs that a covert message has been passed to the child alter, and it should be thoroughly explored as soon as possible. The earlier you detect this and address it, the better for you and your entire system.
One effective approach is to exploit the distrust of Self to increase the fear of Other. This tactic, successfully employed, will encourage the target survivor to separate themselves from other reliable sources of support and make them emotionally dependent on the predator, who can then manipulate the survivor as they wish.
If this is done right, the survivor will believe at each step that the thoughts and feelings are their own, rather than things being suggested to them. For outside observers, it will become clear over time that some other influence has been at work, but by the time this recognition is possible, the predator will already have closed off their prey from outside intervention. The survivor will have been coached to believe that the predator is the only one who has their best interests at heart, that others are jealous of the relationship and want to destroy it, that others will say anything to pull the survivor away, and that they are trying to hurt the survivor by doing so. Intervention at this point only serves as proof that the predator is right.