Too many writing projects and not enough time! I guess it’s time to drag out another old chestnut from the storage trunk of thoughts and see if I can make a blog post out of it…
Have you ever noticed the tendency of people to feel bad for “telling on” someone else?
As survivors, of course, we have a heightened awareness of this feeling, since so many of us learned not to tell under threat of dire consequences, but it’s not a feeling that is limited to survivors. In fact, it seems like a pretty universal feeling.
People are worried that there might be some kind of backlash…
Or they worry that someone will be angry with them…
Or they want to protect someone by not breaking bad news to them…
Or they think it’s none of their business…
Or they just don’t want to get involved…
If you think about it that way, the threats that were used to make us all too afraid to “tell” were really only emphasizing a message that everyone is learning. But what a terrible message…
Why should the person who exposes wrongdoing ever feel like they did something wrong?
Why are we all bending over backwards to protect the person who actually did the wrong thing?
This is the kind of mindset that allowed many of us to be abused for years without relief, even if we believe there were adults who knew (or at least had an idea) that it was happening.
This is also the kind of mindset that allows crime to flourish at all levels – from the streets to the board room. Someone always knows what’s going on, what was done, who did it – but regardless of whether the justification is that “they’d kill me if I ratted” or “I’d lose my job if I blew the whistle”, the end result is the same. The criminals are protected by the conspiring silence of everyone around them.
It’s the kind of mindset that allows teenagers to bully each other until they commit suicide or go on murderous rampages, and everyone knows it’s happening, but nobody says anything until it’s too late.
It’s the kind of mindset that causes us to teach our children that “nobody likes a tattle-tale” and end the lesson there, so that we can raise another generation of people who are afraid to “tell” on anyone, for any reason.
It’s also the kind of mindset that allows someone to present themselves as a hero for daring to “tell” something, even if what they’re telling is lies. We’re all so impressed with the strength it takes to tell, that we don’t bother to question the content of what we’re being told, and we certainly don’t bother checking it out to see if it’s true. Society at large is so conditioned against “telling” that we can actually be manipulated through a false show of courage.
It’s so ingrained, so habitual, so taken for granted by absoutely everyone, that it doesn’t even stand out as odd or unusual to hear someone agonizing over whether to tell something… we never even ask why they’re hesitating. It seems obvious.
But as survivors… we also know what that hesitation can cost. We know how much damage can be done, while the world is protecting perpetrators with a shield of conspiring silence. We know what it is to suffer through what the silence hides, and how desperately we wished that someone, anyone, would have the courage to help us, by daring to break the silence.
And is the situation always that serious? No, of course not. But if nobody dares to “tell” in the small situations, then is it any wonder that nobody dares to do it when the situation is that serious?
So it all matters. Small or large, every conspiring silence causes damage somewhere, to someone – if nothing else, by simply reinforcing the idea that silence is preferrable to speaking the truth.
I can’t change the world. I can’t change everyone’s perceptions or change how everyone does things.
But I can change what I do. My complicit silence, and the complicit silence of everyone around me, stole decades out of my life. The complicit silence of society allows crimes large and small to be committed with impunity every day.
I am speaking, not only in defiance my own history of secrecy and silence exacted by threats and torture, but also in defiance of the social malaise, the mindless willingness to protect the criminal at the expense of the victim.
My complicit silence has come to an end.
I will not let someone else’s wrongdoing be hidden and protected by my fear or my indifference – I will not hide the truth with my silence.
And the more of us who join together in speaking the truth – about anything, large or small – the more we change the currently prevailing perception that the criminals and the perps and the liars have the power, and that the truth should not be spoken, about anything, anywhere, because nobody dares to speak it.
I dare.
How about you?
We are (always have been) really struggling with whether to tell or not tell things that happened.
Keeping secrets for other people is really hard work.
Thank you a lot for this post. It gives us a lot to think about.
Pilgrims
Comment by pilgrimchild — April 10, 2010 @ 9:16 pm
I agree. I also think that coming clean about wrongs I have done to others is important as well.
Comment by adifferentcorner — April 12, 2010 @ 3:35 am
hello Pilgrims –
Keeping secrets in general is hard work, I think. Our own or someone else’s, for whatever reason. And keeping them is not beyond understanding either. There are lots of things that make telling the truth more complicated than it should be. But still, I think truth is the better option most of the time.
Comment by RockerGirl — April 12, 2010 @ 10:47 am
hello adifferentcorner –
Thanks for your comment.
I completely agree with you… think this is probably the hardest part of truth-telling, but also the most important. If we can’t hold ourselves to a standard of honesty, then it’s a bit hypocritical to comment on anyone else’s.
Comment by RockerGirl — April 12, 2010 @ 10:49 am
I do believe that speaking our makes a difference. The change is agonizing slow. The impact really unknown other than it is the right thing to do.
Take the Catholic Church. Those that first had the courage to speak have made a huge impact. So we know their names? Are they honored in our society? Do the ones that can speak out now seek those that went before them out and acknowledge what they accomplished? No they do not. Did those that first spoke out know that they were causing change? I do not think so. They just spoke out as it was the right thing to do.
The first therapist to go public about MKULTRA lost her license for practicing in areas that she was not qualified to practice. I do not think it was some great conspiracy. Just people who are afraid of change.
Global warming is not good science. It is profitable. Speaking out against it is not easy.
The US Department of Education released a report in 2004 stating sexual abuse is prolific in public schools. There has been not action taken yet.
Speaking the truth is hard and really has no reward other than to yourself. People will not join until it is safe.
Comment by MFF — April 19, 2010 @ 6:00 am
“People will not join until it is safe.”
Unfortunately very true. And there is nothing for the masses to join until a few brave souls have had the courage to risk everything on the truth… even though they lose everything because of their courage.
There are “people”… and there are pioneers.
Comment by RockerGirl — April 20, 2010 @ 11:57 am
Hi,
are you really breaking the silence if you do it under the anonymity of a online persona such as rocker girl? Just a question I was thinking about…
Your blog has me thinking. Your writing is well crafted and hard to stop reading. I look forward to making additional comments.
Noodles
Comment by morenoodles — April 22, 2010 @ 6:37 pm
Have you read any of my posts about online safety?
Publishing any personally identifying information on the web is kind of a stupid thing to do.
I’m glad you like the blog otherwise though.
Comment by RockerGirl — April 23, 2010 @ 11:18 am
Good point rocker girl! Good point!
Comment by morenoodles — April 24, 2010 @ 8:28 pm